I actually am reliving the Prius tire issue with my FR-S... last year I let the tire salesman convince me that the newest Yokohama all seasons were actually really good after getting a nail in my very well used Goodrich g-force tires.
The g-force summer tires made the car a hecking go-kart on rails and I loved every bit of it
The Yokohama tires I got now feel like the original Prius tires which are fun don't get me wrong, but I'm back to squealing the rears when turning from any stop
Moral of the story is that all seasons will forever be a less than ideal performer, unless you like being "that guy" who sounds like they're hooning every corner