I am thinking about "separate the art from the artist" because there is a lot of that going around Twitter today regarding J.K. Rowling's continued flirtation with TERFness. 

Look, Harry Potter means nothing to me, I tried reading it and it was nothing I hadn't seen done better before, I didn't have any kids seeing its tricks done for the first time in my life to sympathize with, so cutting Rowling's future work out of my life means nothing to me.

But.

I learnt a lot about drawing and running big projects working under John K.

After the Buzzfeed article revealed the staggering scope of his continued grooming and attempted abuse of underage women, there was a period where I felt like all my skills were fundamentally tainted by having his teaching as their foundation. I *have* to separate his work and his lessons from him as a person if I'm going to function as a professional artist.

A creator embeds attitudes in their work, intentionally and unintentionally. And they put lessons about their craft and the world in their work, intentionally and unintentionally. Once they've revealed some of their worse attitudes it becomes a lot easier to look back at their work and see the poison under the surface. Ultimately there can be a point where you have to acknowledge that the person you have grown into is just not a person who can be down with the politics and ideals of a creator whose work was formative to you.

And that, I think, is when "separating the art from the artist" becomes imperative. Examine what you learnt from a creator you loved in your youth, look at who they've become, and ask if you're cool with supporting someone like that with your money and your recommendations.

Orson Scott Card's SF was important to teen me, but every time someone tries to discuss Ender's Game I'm gonna note how much of a total homophobe he is.I learnt a lot about making comics from Dave Sim's notes but any discussion I'm gonna have about him is gonna note that he basically became an MRA chud after a while. Doug TenNapel's art is divinely hilarious and he's also a total rightwinger who mocked me personally on his BBS. John Krickfalusi taught the whole animation industry some lessons about making limited animation really WORK while leaving a vast chasm of pain in his wake.

Your heros and heroines are not perfect. Some of them are much more imperfect than others, and will come to a point where you have to... look at what their work taught you, and pry that apart from who they are and the things they've done. And maybe decide that every time their work comes up in the future you will quietly mention the things they did that made you want to throw everything they taught you into the trash along with them.

Separate the art from the artist; cherish the good parts of their work that shaped who you are, use the tools you got from them to make work that celebrates the values you have that they would hate. Think hard about whether you want to celebrate their work and pass it on to other people, especially the next generation, because that gives the person they turned out to be a platform to spread their current ideas from.

Anyway. I should stop pontificating about this and get back to using the tools I got from assorted creators I've disowned, and from ones I still love, to make some comics.

Follow

I am thinking about "separate the art from the artist" because there is a lot of that going around Twitter today regarding J.K. Rowling's continued flirtation with TERFness. 

@anthracite To borrow the commonly (mis)quoted Bruce Lee dedication (which itself appears to be adapted from an earlier quote from, of all people, Mao Zedong):

"Research your own experience; absorb what is useful, reject what is useless and add what is essentially your own."

I am thinking about "separate the art from the artist" because there is a lot of that going around Twitter today regarding J.K. Rowling's continued flirtation with TERFness. 

@Goldkin

Yeah, that sums it up a lot more elegantly!

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Awoo Space

Awoo.space is a Mastodon instance where members can rely on a team of moderators to help resolve conflict, and limits federation with other instances using a specific access list to minimize abuse.

While mature content is allowed here, we strongly believe in being able to choose to engage with content on your own terms, so please make sure to put mature and potentially sensitive content behind the CW feature with enough description that people know what it's about.

Before signing up, please read our community guidelines. While it's a very broad swath of topics it covers, please do your best! We believe that as long as you're putting forth genuine effort to limit harm you might cause – even if you haven't read the document – you'll be okay!