Follow

genderpol, language, subtoot, birdsite, Discourse, vent, vent, no seriously, turn back, vent 

I swear to god anybody I see getting militant over the difference between "transwomen" and "trans women" is getting the boot, immediately. Getting uptight over the supposed semiotic content of a space is just a bridge too far for me. You can ask for it. You can explain why it's important. You can even debate it with me. But if you flatly insist, I'm gonna insist right back, and I'll be pointing at the door, because I don't think that's a cultural authority you have—or need.

And yes, this is really a thing. And I have friends who are eagerly retweeting it. And they're already digging in and trying to tar anybody who gets it wrong as a transphobe.

And I just won't. I'm so fucking tired of armchair activists trying to dictate usage like this. It's so fucking prim and normative, and it feels so much like repainting the goddamn barn for the 5,000th time so you don't have to do your other chores.

And if your first reaction was an impulse to lecture me about why this space is really, really important and we need this and this group uses it in this context and blah blah blah, that's exactly the problem. This distinction means NOTHING to most people.

You're trying to quiz people on a 300-level class when they haven't even got their Trans Politics GED yet. If _I_ don't even give a shit, someone who's struggled with gender issues for approximately 36 years (if wanting very badly to be a pink plastic cyborg ponygirl at age 8 counts), all this is gonna do is help the 4channer types tar us as a bunch of insane prudes who want to remake culture in our own image.

We do, of course. But don't TELL them that. O:)

I understand the urge to be militant, I really do. But if there's one thing I learned from my stint as a Christian, it's that the best way to convert is to make your movement look FRIENDLY. Save the spite for actual TERFs and reactionaries, not for people who didn't learn Trans Prescriptivist Etiquette Du Jour before they had the unmitigated nerve to address you.

"I know this may sound pedantic but..." Yeah. It sounds pedantic. And I should have stood up to you instead of venting on Masto, but there is nothing more TEDIOUS to me than talking to someone that concerned about the purity of their semiotic environment. You are going to accomplish NOTHING against the TERFs this way.

genderpol, language, subtoot, birdsite, Discourse, vent, vent, no seriously, turn back, vent 

@zebratron2084 For the more marxist take on this: revolutions fail when the vanguard party insists that it is their job to lecture to one another instead of... being a fuckin' vanguard party. You don't get the man on the ground involved with ivory tower semantics debates; they'll get bored and go home and it's all the easier for them to ignore you later.

genderpol, language, subtoot, birdsite, Discourse, vent, vent, no seriously, turn back, vent 

@zebratron2084

... oh FFS, now what??

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Awoo Space

Awoo.space is a Mastodon instance where members can rely on a team of moderators to help resolve conflict, and limits federation with other instances using a specific access list to minimize abuse.

While mature content is allowed here, we strongly believe in being able to choose to engage with content on your own terms, so please make sure to put mature and potentially sensitive content behind the CW feature with enough description that people know what it's about.

Before signing up, please read our community guidelines. While it's a very broad swath of topics it covers, please do your best! We believe that as long as you're putting forth genuine effort to limit harm you might cause – even if you haven't read the document – you'll be okay!