Ultima IV had 8 party members at once, and it definitely made battles feel very slow when you had to cycle through giving all of them commands one at a time.
@dodec Oh yeah, there are definitely good reasons to have less than that. Suikoden's 6-member party worked pretty well, largely because the "auto" option was good and the battles were streamlined (multiple attacks happen at once, etc)
@dodec Oh! It's been a while here too.
That reminds me a little of final fantasy 4, where the entire party functions like that; you don't get a say in who's in the party at any given moment, it's all just what the story dictates
@Felthry
You can. I don't remember if they gain XP or let you change their equipment around (it's been a while) but you do at least command them in battle.