katt, migrating 🌟 🌈 @starkatt@awoo.space

So, conclusion: Star Trek TNG actually has a pretty cool example of how reading about a culture is not nearly the same as being an actual participant in it.

When Worf interacts with other Klingons on the show, there's a distinct cultural divide.

He's been raised with heavy emphasis on Klingon values such as aggression and honor, but only as seen through the filter of Federation (i.e. 1990s american liberal) values.

As practiced by native Kilingons, Klingon cultural values are expressed very differently than how Worf understands them. This frequently catches him by surprise and makes him feel like an outside.

Now here's the interesting part, which was implicit but not overt in the show.

Worf's parents were raising him basically on the Wikipedia version of Klingon culture. They did their very best to expose him to Klingon rituals and cultural values, but only with the imperfect knowledge of cultural outsiders. There was no Klingon community on earth they could participate in. They could teach the declarative content and nominal meaning of the culture, but none of the actual texture as practiced.

Worf wasn't raised by other Klingons though. When he was very young his dad died in a space battle with the Federation, and he ended up being adopted by a Russian couple on earth.

They genuinely loved him, and wanted what was best for their son. As part of this, they didn't want him to grow up alienated from his cultural identity as a Klingon, and made a point of exposing him to Klingon cultural traditions as a major part of his upbringing.

As teased last night, here's a thread on Lt. Worf and cultural context:

Starting from the very basics: Lieutenant Worf appears in Star Trek TNG as the tactical officer of the Enterprise. He's a Klingon, trek's Proud Warrior Race. (the proud warrior race thing has both inherent problems and issues of racial coding, but I'll leave those aside for now.)

bedtime for me now, though 💜

Hey, if any of y'all know a good introduction to the concepts of affect I'd really like to pass it along. It's an increasingly important part of my understanding of the world and I want to share that with people, but I don't actually feel prepared to explain affect clearly.

@starkatt hi I've spent literally all day watching youtube film criticism and it has prompted me to want to write more, even if informally.

@starkatt another topic I've been wanting to talk about for a while and need I remember to actually do so: Worf, cultural context, and the inadequacy of received texts as cultural guides.

my brain seems to have made the affective shift from "it's summer!" to "it's winter!" in like three days and that feels kind of strange.

I should probably maybe stop referring to every piece of critical opinion or analysis as a take? idk.

mumble mumble please remind me to talk about harry potter as millennial mythological framework and what embracing myth means in a post-irony culture.

Better take: myths are a built-in part of our culture and a lot of people seem to ignore that, or give disproportionate value to modern myths over ancient ones.

Myths can be good, actually.

@Azure heck yeah! Will look more into this tomorrow.

@Azure oh my gosh canon accepted.

(is there a mythological foundation of this?)

@aesmael I've seen this particular ad posted every three days for the better part of a month now and it's like gee, I wonder why you're not finding enough applicants.