so, we may have found our first moon orbiting another planet? advances.sciencemag.org/lens/a

it isn't confirmed yet (much like between the first detection of an exoplanet {1988} and the first confirmed one {1992, or '95 if we're talking main sequence stars}, this'll take years), but the evidence so far is well in favor of the object in question being a moon instead of a planet and honestly I'm excited as hell for this?

sure it's literally the easiest possible object to find of its type (a neptune-sized gas giant orbiting a superjovian at a great distance), but the fact that we've found something like this at all is kind of amazing

also it's a fucking -small gas giant orbiting another, larger gas giant-. that may very well have formed in place. if that's confirmed that bodes super well for finding like, actual habitable moons around gas giants in the future

@Thaminga a gas giant orbiting a gas giant, I wonder if the smaller one also has moons and if so just how deep orbital mechanics will physically let you go. Moons orbiting moons orbiting moons.

@Felthry I could definitely see four steps down happening (massive, almost-brown-dwarf gas giant -> small gas giant -> Mars-sized rocky moon -> tiny asteroidlike moonlet), though that would take a pretty huge system to really work out and sheer luck to actually like, exist

maybe around like, a type A or B star

@Thaminga Go one step further by having the biggest gas giant orbit the distal star of a binary star system

@Thaminga oh, of course!

Then put a space station in orbit around the smallest mini-moon, because hey, why not, maybe some aliens live on this world that surely has some _really weird_ weather conditions

@Felthry orbits like that won't affect weather conditions too much, I don't think!

now, astronomical events though? yeah those are going to be all sorts of fucked up

@Thaminga I mean, the sun would be periodically eclipsed by one of several larger bodies, I feel like that would do _something_ to the weather

@Thaminga Unless you somehow manage to have the planetary system at a very high inclination, but that's even _more_ improbable

@Felthry There'd definitely be some level of inclination at least, but yeah; eclipses like this don't actually last for long enough to affect the overall weather patterns too greatly!

@Thaminga A very high inclination is quite improbable though!

I wonder what it'd take to get a planet with a moon orbiting at near-90° inclination... it'd almost certainly have to be a captured asteroid or Oort cloud object, maybe even an extrasolar asteroid

@Felthry I didn't say high, but even low inclinations will radically decrease your chances of an eclipse; an object orbiting Neptune at the same distance the Moon has from Earth would already move three planetary radii above and below the planet at an inclination of only 10°; while this is high for regularly formed moons, remember that this is with respect to the -orbit-, and regular moons are typically coplanar with their planets' rotation axes (which can be well, anything).

@Thaminga Oh, good point. I didn't think about planets with highly inclined rotation axes.

@Thaminga @Felthry Now I'm wishing I'd taken screenshots of some of the buck-wild systems I've seen in Elite Dangerous (which claims to do a rough modeling of system accretion).

Here's one I found on a list of nearby Interesting Systems: edsm.net/en/system/bodies/id/2

@starkatt @Thaminga we should really try elite dangerous sometime, supposedly it's pretty good

@Felthry @Thaminga I enjoyed it a lot! It's very, very pretty and gives a sense of scale I haven't seen anywhere else.

@starkatt @Thaminga I'd expect a similar sense of scale as No Man's Sky?

Kerbal Space Program also does a pretty good job of making you realize how big space is but that's just one solar system and a pretty small one at that

@Felthry @Thaminga Oh NMS left me *really* disappointed in terms of system modeling after coming from ED.

@starkatt @Thaminga it does leave a bit to be desired but I can understand it for gameplay reasons

@Felthry @Thaminga Yeah in Elite systems are Actual Size. You superluminal cruise faster when away from gravity wells but things like a distant binary can take ages to fly to.

Also there's the literal entire milky way galaxy to explore. hundreds of millions of systems.

@Felthry @Thaminga This is how far I traveled, after 100 hours of gameplay, a good chunk of which was spent on long-rage exploration.

@starkatt @Thaminga I mean, that's a _really long way_ to go in only 100 hours!

@Felthry @Thaminga That was with a max jump range of somewhere a bit under 50LY.

@Felthry @Thaminga If you really hustle you can do several jumps per minute. Even then it takes weeks of travel for dedicated players to get to Sagittarius A*.

@starkatt @Thaminga The question remains: is it worth the time and effort to get there?

@Felthry @Thaminga Go exploring and you can see some really beautiful things. Here's a (extremely remote) ring outpost in the Sadr Region nebula about 1.8kLY from Sol, with the North American and Pelican Nebulae in the background.

There's another screenshot from inside a planetary nebula that I haven't shared because I want to keep it *mine*.

@Felthry @Thaminga And it all feels a lot more special when you have to really go a long ways for it, y'know?

Also uhh I realize now I kinda hijacked the thread. Apologies if that was obnoxious.

@starkatt @Felthry @Thaminga Yeah, ED is seriously something I've been wanting to check out. They do some amazing, fascinating stuff

@Felthry @Thaminga I was big on exploration but you can also do pew pew or commodity schlepping or tour guiding.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Awoo Space

Awoo.space is a Mastodon instance where members can rely on a team of moderators to help resolve conflict, and limits federation with other instances using a specific access list to minimize abuse.

While mature content is allowed here, we strongly believe in being able to choose to engage with content on your own terms, so please make sure to put mature and potentially sensitive content behind the CW feature with enough description that people know what it's about.

Before signing up, please read our community guidelines. While it's a very broad swath of topics it covers, please do your best! We believe that as long as you're putting forth genuine effort to limit harm you might cause – even if you haven't read the document – you'll be okay!