assuming a game is equally easy to play with either, would you rather use:

-F

@Felthry depends heavily on genre imo

even ignoring difficulty, different genres feel better with different control schemes

@monorail i guess some genres just can't be equally easy with either, too, really

dwarf fortress with a controller just plain doesn't make sense
-F

@Felthry @monorail depends on the controller, sth like the Steam Controller that just straight up comes with trackball emulation would probably work

@noiob @monorail dwarf fortress uses keyboard shortcuts very heavily though; even an emulated keyboard would be hard
-F

@Felthry @monorail you can map a staggering amount of keypresses, macros, whatever to the Steam Controller with key combos and the like, you can even map touch-based menus that'll pop up a visual indicator when used