Follow

typh is considering stopping esperanto and learning another conlang in its stead. what should i do

keep in mind im also learning french and japanese

esperanto, lewd adj. 

appealing to kink won't save you now, esperanto

it seems the croud consensus is that i slow down on esperanto but don't give up on it completely

i'm down. okay, so what conlang should i focus on in its stead? im not gonna make this one a poll cos there are so many, just tell me what your recommendations are

so far i've got recommendations for lojban (which i'm already learning) and toki pona

any other thoughts?

@typhlosion from the sound of it, esperanto has just been frustrating to you, so i'm voting to go for something else

esperanto-negative opinion 

@typhlosion matter of personal taste here, but I think literally every single conlang I've ever browsed is both better constructed and more beautiful than esperanto.

re: esperanto-negative opinion 

@elilla tbh? agreed

lojban is more interesting, toki pona has an intriguing premise, even the fantasy languages built to have realistic imperfections are aesthetically nice. esperanto just feels like a boring, simplified romance language with a bunch of ossified outdated design choices from the early 1900s

@Felthry that's one of the ones i'm considering! i'd like to see what different folks recommend though

@typhlosion you could also do like, sindarin or klingon, and learn something that's completely useless outside of conventions

@Felthry in fairness, lojban is also pretty useless in most situations. conlangs in general are pretty useless

anyway i considered it, but the problem is that i don't really have an emotional connection to the source material of klingon or sindarin

or really any artlang other than maybe the dwarven language of paolini's inheritance books, but i'm not sure learning material for that language even exists

@typhlosion we should read the inheritance series again sometime.... it's been a long time and i remember them being Pretty Good

@Felthry the first one is pretty bland imo but the second one and onward really make the world feel like its own thing!

@typhlosion@awoo.space i'm figuring that a lot of people will have solid suggestions of specific conlangs, but I wanted to toss this one into the pile, just in case: what about making your own?

@InspectorCaracal i am like, constantly devoting 1% of my brainpower to thinking about this exact thing

tbh i need to just sit down and develop a grammar and get cracking on a swadesh list or something

@typhlosion@awoo.space conlanging is GREAT

I have an extremely slow-progress conlang I've been dabbling with for ages and it's loads of fun, especially if you ignore the criticisms of people whose idea of a conlang is 50% academic linguistics jargon

@InspectorCaracal japanese has been really inspirational tbh! it's always fun to have your brain very slightly broken by a language with a grammar that's pretty different from your own

somehow i already have two really sophisticated writing systems developed and i dont even have the language yet

(well i have the phonotactics because they informed how the scripts work but not the language itself)

@InspectorCaracal i'll post more about those writing systems at some point! probably when i have, uh, something to write in them

@typhlosion@awoo.space also, if you like playing with conlang but find yourself overwhelmed by the task of inventing vocabulary, may I suggest Vulgar Lang https://www.vulgarlang.com/

@InspectorCaracal honestly the task of inventing vocabulary isn't as onerous as the decisions regarding what should be a root vs what should be a compound or built in some other way

@typhlosion@awoo.space haha, yeahhh <.< or the underlying cultural implications of which words have multiple synonyms or antonyms, or which meanings are collected into the same word, not to mention homophones and homonyms....

@shoofle toki ponaaaaaaaaa........

where should i start learning that?

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Awoo Space

Awoo.space is a Mastodon instance where members can rely on a team of moderators to help resolve conflict, and limits federation with other instances using a specific access list to minimize abuse.

While mature content is allowed here, we strongly believe in being able to choose to engage with content on your own terms, so please make sure to put mature and potentially sensitive content behind the CW feature with enough description that people know what it's about.

Before signing up, please read our community guidelines. While it's a very broad swath of topics it covers, please do your best! We believe that as long as you're putting forth genuine effort to limit harm you might cause – even if you haven't read the document – you'll be okay!