whee even more contrarian politics
Something tells me I'm gonna be spending a lot of time in the next two weeks looking for my old 20th Century Russia textbooks to explain why, in point of fact, communism is not some good shit. :|
Socialism is some good shit. At the VERY least, communism needs to be run through a good-quality filter that removes particles of Stalinist and Leninist contaminants.
I sentence all you young antifa whelps to eat in a Polish milkbar for the rest of eternity.
whee even more contrarian politics
@zebratron2084 Communism's got problems for sure. Good thing we have this republic democracy hybrid with no problems whatsoever!
whee even more contrarian politics
@zebratron2084 @mawr Or, you know, we could talk about all the non-Russian communist -- really more akin to anarchomutualist than classic Marxist -- implementations and remind people that Russia is not a role model, but a strong counterexample.
whee even more contrarian politics
@literorrery @mawr I have a horrible sinking feeling that any such argument among the three of us would swiftly descending into semantics over what constitutes "communism" exactly.
But I'll eagerly concede that there were quite a few socialist governments, esp. in Latin America, that would probably have been quite humane but never got to Do Their Thing because of US Cold War interference (read: "discreetly shooting people").
whee even more contrarian politics
@zebratron2084 @literorrery I know you know that socialism isn't a form of governance, it's an economic platform. The closest thing we have to the practices of socialism in the form of a system of governance is loosely defined as "communism" with many many many different methods and applications named after the dictators who attempted to put their method in practice.
As a result, "Communism" is frequently used as an umbrella term for socialist governance.
whee even more contrarian politics
@literorrery @zebratron2084 So when folks say "communism is some good shit" they probably have an ideal form in mind that's never actually been tried on a large scale.
whee even more contrarian politics
@zebratron2084 @mawr There's a huge amount of clustering in that phrase: "the same thing." Lots of things have happened to "the right." Some of it I don't think can happen to us. Some of it can and should, like defining our moral center. Some of it can and shouldn't, like using our out-groups as a tool for generating in-group cohesion. Seen way too much of that, and it bugs me.
If I'm to offer more than vague reassurances, I could do with more clarity.