Put another way:
If the last three games that I found had a lasting impact were We Know The Devil, Undertale, and Night in the Woods, what should I play next?
@starkatt i can think of a bunch of text adventures but not a lot else comes immediately to mind. please keep me in the loop on your findings
@starkatt ummm Gone Home...
@Fuego Already played it. Maybe it should have gone on the list. Thanks!
@starkatt oxenfree? I haven't played it yet but it matches your criteria and people say super good stuff about it.
Kentucky Route Zero is awesome and they donated to TransRelief too!!!
I had a weird time with it on PS4 but now I think I'm ready to tackle it again
@starkatt is unfinished swan on pc? I loved that game.
@Fuego PlayStation only afaik :(
@starkatt Hadean Lands (text adventure), Talos Principle, Fool's Errand.
@starkatt Night. In. The. Woods. OMG. I loved that game so much!! Emotional gutpunch though.
Slime Rancher is kinda cute and fun, though pretty early on, last I played.
The others I'd recommend have already been shared. ^^
@starkatt OH!!
If you haven't already played it: The Stanley Parable.
Gosh y'all have a lot of really good suggestions and I've already played most of them. Will definitely have to check out some of the others <3